Natural resource myths

Julian Simon, as quoted by Ed Regis in Wired Magazine, February 1997

“This is the litany: our resources are running out. The air is bad, the water worse. The planet’s species are dying off-more exactly, we’re killing them-at the staggering rate of 100,000 per year, a figure that works out to almost 2,000 species per week, 300 per day, 10 per hour, another dead species every six minutes. We’re trashing the planet, washing away topsoil, paving over our farmlands, systematically deforesting our wilderness, decimating the biota, and ultimately killing ourselves.

The world is getting progressively poorer, and it’s all because of population, or more precisely, over-population. There’s a finite store of resources on our pale blue dot, spaceship Earth, our small and fragile tiny planet, and we’re fast approaching its ultimate carrying capacity. The limits to growth are finally upon us, we’re living on borrowed time. The laws of population growth are inexorable. Unless we act decisively, the final result is written in stone: mass poverty, famine, starvation, and death.

Time is short, and we have to act now.

That’s the standard and canonical litany. It’s been drilled into our heads so far and so forcefully that to hear it yet once more is...well,it’s almost reassuring. It’s comforting, oddly consoling - at least we’re face to face with the enemies: consumption, population, mindless growth. and we know the solution: cut back, contract, make do with less, “live simply so that others may simply live.”

There’s just one problem with The Litany, just one slight little wee imperfection: every item in that dim and dreary recitation, each and every last claim, is false. Incorrect. At variance with the truth.

Not the way it is, folks.

Source: Eat First

Reprint permission given by AgAir Update, P.O. Box 850, Perry, GA 31069 - an international agricultural aviation publication.

Return to Spreading the Facts